Monday, October 03, 2005

ELECTION COVERAGE & COMMENTARY

In 2001, new regulations under the Parliamentary Elections Act allowed the use of the internet for promoting political parties or candidates, by the parties or candidates themselves. Parties/candidates can use the internet as a publicity vehicle during the election period, but cannot exploit the technology’s powerful mobilisational capabilities. For example, they cannot push out online petitions. They are also limited to a “positive list” of acceptable practices, which has not been updated to include newer technologies. As a result, audio/video-streaming is banned.

Non-party websites that have been deemed to be "political" in nature (eg Thinkcentre.org) are banned from carrying election publicity.

The Parliamentary Elections Act (PEA) regulates publicity during elections (from the day the elections are announced through a “writ” until the close of polls). The law pertains mainly to election advertising, but “election advertising” is defined broadly enough to include “material that can reasonably be regarded as intended… to… enhance the standing of… political parties, candidates or groups of candidates”, whether or not their names are mentioned. Furthermore, such material can be treated as election advertising even if it is “intended to achieve any other purpose as well”. This suggests that election commentary could come under the PEA.

News is exempted from the PEA. The news exception applies to publication “in a newspaper in any medium or in a radio or television broadcast”. The phrase “newspaper in any medium” presumably includes online newspapers. Does this mean that a citizen-journalist could start a news blog about the elections without worrying about the PEA? Not necessarily. Although “newspapers” are not defined within the Act, Singapore law does define newspapers within the Newspaper and Printing Presses Act. Reading the NPPA together with the PEA, we can assume that the PEA is referring to licensed newspapers. Since standalone websites do not have newspaper permits, they might not qualify for the PEA’s news exception. The upshot of this is that the election coverage of Straits Times Interactive would be considered news, but that of Little Speck or Think Centre might not. Similarly, streaming video or podcasts on a Mediacorp site (licensed under the Broadcasting Act) would be exempted from the PEA as news, but similar content on an independent website would not.

Also exempted from the PEA is the “transmission by an individual to another individual, on a non-commercial basis on what is commonly known as the Internet, of his own political views”. In other words, one-to-one communication will not be treated as election advertising. However, emailing a group of people would come under the PEA if it “can reasonably be regarded as intended… to… enhance the standing of… political parties, candidates or groups of candidates”. (Does this only apply to “relevant persons” or to all individuals? – to check)

What then does the PEA require? Election advertising must carry the names and addresses of the printers and publishers. Advertising is banned on polling day, although pre-existing posters and web material need not be taken down. The PEA also bans the publication of any election survey – including those covering voting intentions or election issues – during the election period, until the moment that polls close. Also banned during that time is the publication of exit polls and forecasts. This ban applies to all persons, including the news media.

In 2001, the Government instituted new regulations under the PEA governing the internet: the Parliamentary Elections (Election Advertising) Regulations (PER).

Candidates and parties are allowed to use the internet for election advertising. Photos and manifestoes, membership recruitment messages, and announcements of meetings on the web or through email are all explicitly permitted in a so-called “positive list” in the PER. Chat rooms are also allowed.

Emailed advertising must comply with certain conditions. First, the email must include a clear method for the recipient to get in touch with the sender and to remove himself from the email list. The sender must comply with such a request. Second, the email must not contain any statement requesting (even implicitly) that the recipient forward it to others or to republish it. Although it is not an offence for the recipient voluntarily to forward an email or web link, note that (unless you are a candidate or party) only individual-to-individual email is permitted. An individual who receives a campaign message from a party and then forwards it to a group list would be in violation of the PEA. In effect, these rules limit the “viral” effect of the internet, slowing down the spread of campaign messages. Parties that have built up large mailings list would therefore have an advantage over those that count on recipients to forward their messages.

Parties/candidates are permitted to run online discussion forums during elections, but must appoint a moderator who is answerable to the authorities. The moderator must remove “without delay” any postings as directed by the authorities. The moderator must also keep a record of all messages submitted.

Other than parties and candidates, the PER also covers what the Act calls "relevant persons" - defined as individuals or groups (other than parties/candidates) deemed by the Media Development Authority to be providing "political" content. This relates to the MDA's powers under internet class licensing system. Since the mid-1990s, the internet regulators have had the authority to ask "political" and "religious" sites to register themselves. This does not amount to requiring clearance/permission for publication. It is instead an accountability mechanism. Registration requires furnishing the government with details about the individuals behind a political/religious site. Think Centre's website is registered as a political site. Sintercom was asked to register before the 2001 elections, but chose to close down and relocate overseas instead.

Under the PER, "relevant persons" (to sum up: non-party sites that MDA has declared as political sites) are banned from engaging in election advertising.

As at March 2006, the number of "political" sites is small. The question is whether MDA will require more sites to register ahead of the 2006 GE, turning them into "relevant persons" under the PER and banning them from election commentary.

What about blogs? So far, no blog has been declared a political site, but since blogs are nothing more than easily-editable websites, there doesn't appear to be any legal reason why a local blog could not be required to register as a political site.

Many Singaporeans feel that there's a need for a truly independent source of news and commentary during elections. Logistically, it would not be difficult to put together a team of citizen journalists and volunteer editors to cover election rallies and put out detailed reports and commentaries via emailed newsletters and a website. South Korea's Ohmynews has shown the power of such citizen journalism. In Singapore, it may be hard to sustain such an effort on a permanent basis, but there would probably be enough energy and interest during election time to get such a project going.

Under the PER, the legality of such an initiative would depend on whether the MDA considers it a "political" site. If so, it would not qualify to use the internet as parties/candidates, nor would it necessarily qualify for the PER exemption that licensed news providers enjoy.

13 comments:

WOW Gold said...

buy eden gold
eden gold
cheap eden gold

Buying WOW Gold said...

Effectively on-line it is easy to go to a video exactly where among the list of event scientific studies that had got to experiment with the actual guidebook indicates the amount silver they've got produced in addition to illustrates which he or she is within the actual hosting server.

cambridge satchels said...

Love is always can be a reason that can explain why we always buy Cambridge satchel. She is always can be most know that women need. Know we tired of winter cold, immediately launched color coat of paint sandals and decorations. Cambridge satchel discern the ladies for the purchase of a cool and refreshing feeling of handbags, which launched seemingly weave? Man-made fibers handbags, change hemp rope handle, Resort feel and return to. A change color, black night life desire and will awaken, two kinds of color, two kind of mood.

Black is always Cambridge satchel love, but the signature is coat of paint and color butyl two material, the black artificial fiber new look and golden cyworld nail and chains hand wan, compared with white series, this design must belong to clubbing look first choice, have rejected the gold chain heavy body, and hemp rope hand wan design chooses, care is dye-in-the-wood.

Cambridge satchel artificial fiber handbags series in last summer already exposure, but the wake of god's white series, abandon use silver triangle logo, and replaced with a wooden DaoSanJiao, with white bag body very look line, add hemp rope handle, already tell you she is representative of the summer, be the same as series also has a hand in chains in style.

The name of this type of leather bag "trente" one word in the French for "30" like, since 1946 from the home of the famous dior address-Paris, longs for 30 th. The long history of the famous construction has a private studio, dior current art director John Galliano sir is here with great concentration carve design work pieces. Today, the building or global flagship store, the seat of the dior. Michel DE montaigne avenue with its many luxury brand shop together and all over the world, it is absolutely Paris not miss landmark.

Cambridge satchels Leather bag with elegant details are full of the female's charm, like a beautiful evening dress. This type attract many people and all want to own it. The bag super capacity design, hang down plait appearance elegant decorous, soft hang adorn just a action can be launched into a corolla shape, form the spacious open his mouth. This also makes this leather interior space is capacious, and use convenient and comfortable.

Women leather jackets said...

nice post love it

chuangjiawow said...

thank you for your sharing~
it's so good !
I like it so much~


______________________________
enjoy game so much!
wow gold buyingWOW Gold CheapWorld Of Warcraft Gold

Anonymous said...

Efficiently on-lineCheap Runescape Goldit is possible to go to a movie in which the large choice of occasion scientific studies which had have got to try out the particular guide book suggests just how much sterling silver they've got manufactured in accessory for demonstrates which he Cheap MapleStory Mesosor even she actually is from the actual web hosting machine.

Anonymous said...

To get this sort of critters you undoubtedly dog collar require being urged to assist you to certify that possibly enjoying all the presents and they are near practical fitness once review. If you've gained over one puppy, subsequent the rrs really a must as you would like make sure that the dog carrier kitties may be within the perfect luxury combined with physical health whereas you have been off. Despite the presence of individuals devoid of everyone all round, certify they are being satisfied and content such as www.lovelonglong.com you are going to have them till you go back.

Buy rs gold said...

thanks for your sharing , i like it

www.windows7mart.com said...

I've a speedy internet connection so I guess the Windows update servers were slammed our website since it took more than two hours to download the 59 updates. That was followed by an hour as well as a half of watching Windows install those updates. When it was ultimately finished the method rebooted to apply the updates.

summermobile said...


Also exempted from the PEA is the “transmission by an individual to another individual, on a non-commercial basis on what is commonly known as the Internet, of his own political views”.

http://www.meizu-mx5.com/

Anonymous said...

good
Obat Wasir atau ambeyen
Pengobatan Wasir Ambeien
Obat Wasir dan ambeien
Pengobatan Wasir atau ambeien
Obat Wasir atau Ambeien yang ada di Apotik
Obat Wasir Ambeien di Apotik
Obat Wasir atau Ambeien Apotik
Pengobatan Wasir atau Ambeien di Apotik
Obat Wasir Ambeien Ambeclear
Obat Ambeien Ambeclear
Pengobatan Wasir atau Ambeien Ambeclear
Obat Wasir atau Ambeien dari Ambeclear
Obat Wasir Manjur
Obat Ambeien Manjur
Obat Wasir Ambeien Manjur
Pengobatan Wasir atau Ambeien Manjur
obat kemaluan bernanah
pengobatan kemaluan bernanah
obat kelamin pria bernanah
obat ampuh kemaluan pria bernanah
Obat Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Obat Kemaluan yang Bernanah
Obat Kemaluan Pria yg Bernanah
Obat Ampuh Kemaluan Pria yang Bernanah
Obat Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Resep Obat Kemaluan Bernanah
Resep Obat kelamin Pria Bernanah
Resep Obat Alami Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Cari Obat untuk sakit Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Obat Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Cari Alami Obat Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Cari Tradisional Obat Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Beli Obat Penyakit Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Obat Kemaluan Pria Bernanah
Beli Obat Kemaluan Bernanah
Beli Obat sakit Kemaluan Pria Bernanah

herbal >>> said...

good
Pengobatan manjur Kondiloma Akuminata
Cara Pengobatan manjur Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Yang manjur Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Herbal manjur Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan manjur Kondiloma Akuminata Tanpa Operasi
Pengobatan Manjur Virus Kondiloma Akuminata
Cari Pengobatan Manjur Virus Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Alami Manjur Virus Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Manjur Atasi Virus Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Manjur Hilangkan Virus Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Manjur Infeksi Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Manjur Sembuhkan Infeksi Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Manjur Untuk Infeksi Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Manjur Buat Infeksi Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Tradisional Manjur Infeksi Kondiloma Akuminata

hou said...

The long history of the famous construction has a private studio, dior current art director John Galliano sir is here with great concentration carve design work pieces.
xiaomi redmi note 2 review
meizu mx5 review
meizu review