Thursday, July 06, 2006

WHEN BLOGGERS ENTER MSM, PART 2

"I have been informed that TODAY has suspended my column," writes mrbrown. Thus, Today appears to have acted on the government's statement on opinion columns in mainstream media (see earlier posting). We don't know if there was any explicit instruction from the government to discontinue his column, but Today editors probably felt they could not read the government's letter any other way. The government said that "it is not the role of journalists or newspapers in Singapore to champion issues, or campaign for or against the Government", and implied that mrbrown is a "partisan player in politics", "exploiting his access to the mass media to undermine the Government's standing with the electorate". Indeed, the main intended audience of the government's response to mrbrown's column may have been the editors of Mediacorp Press and SPH, who have been trying to increase their publications' cool quotient by co-opting aspects of online culture, including celebrity bloggers.

The 1990s had the Catherine Lim Affair. Will Singaporeans be talking about the mrbrown affair in the years to come? It is too early to tell what it spells for Singapore media and politics in the long term. One thing, though, is clear: the government is drawing a distinct line between alternative niche media and mainstream mass media. Mrbrown's offence was that his views were "widely circulated in a regular column in a serious newspaper". Presumably, his blog will continue to be tolerated. Indeed, 10 years after the government introduced the class licence and registration rules for the internet, it has yet to block or ban a single political website. (At a conference recently, I put the question to messrs brown and Miyagi: by and large, has the government kept its promise to regulate the internet with a "light touch"? Their answer, at the time: yes.)

While this regulatory distinction between mainstream and alternative media seems clearcut, there remain some question marks over the government's position. First, experts on media regulation usually say that rules should be platform-neutral. Otherwise, especially in an age of digital convergence, you may end up with an inconsistent policy, with the same content being banned on one medium but not on another. But perhaps the distinction being drawn in this case is not a technological one between print and online, but is based on relative reach and influence (like the way cinemas, subscription TV and free-to-air TV are subject to different censorship rules).

Second, what does this mean for newspapers' attempts to move with the times and borrow from online culture, including the Straits Times' much-hyped STOMP? The online activities of registered newspaper companies are accorded a special status: for example, they are considered "news" and thereby exempt from the rules against online electioneering. But, when free-wheeling bloggers and online discussants are co-opted by the likes of STOMP, should they be treated with a light touch a la the rest of cyberspace, or to the "higher standard" of mainstream media since they are circulated with the mainstream media's stamp?

Third, it is one thing to demolish an individual article and declare that it has crossed the OB markers, but it's another thing altogether to decide that the writer is himself permanently out of bounds, and that even his future, unpenned views cannot be published. That is what the suspension of mrbrown's column amounts to. If Today's decision reflects official policy, then it strikes me as a policy of going after the man, not the ball, and is a retrograde step in Singapore's political development.

34 comments:

DramaMama said...

"If Today's decision reflects official policy, then it strikes me as a policy of going after the man, not the ball, and is a retrograde step in Singapore's political development."

Well said, prof. Can't agree more with you on that point.

Anonymous said...

This would not have happen if PAP did not politicise everything deem to their advantage.

PAP should not politicise the media.

I mean it is like PAP have politicise everything including NDP.

But why the need to politicise?

Is controlling Singaporeans right down to the bone that important and advantageous to PAP? Nothing more is important to them?

This would not have happen if the media was not politicise. The determination by PAP to control all things is scary.

They want to control but refuse to be responsible or apologetic when things go wrong is even scarier.

All we ordinary people can do is vote Opposition in every election even if the Opposition loses. I cannot think of any other way to make PAP eat humble pie.

Then no one would have the need to feel fear,tension and paranoid in their own homeland.

PAP has to be Opposition for some time for Singapore's culture and climate to change, that is the only way.

My vote is nothing but many votes is something.Please do not forget today's lesson even if PAP loosen control come GE 2011.

Anonymous said...

I guess only PAP is right and citizens are wrong in these KINDS of situation. These KINDS of situation have repeated many times over the years.

What is more scarier is that PAP took the most popular blogger in Singapore to put on chopping block and use it to show as an example to everyone who wants to blog about politics. (Kai Dao: Open Knife)

It is a very good political move by PAP.It has increased the fear factor by many notches. We are back to the 70s & 80s again.

Most probably after this episode, there will be less activity on political blogs and Singaporeans will be apathetic again which PAP always 'advocates'.

Maybe Mr Brown might even fizzle out.

Anonymous said...

Isnt TODAY guilty of politicization of the issue and being partisan by dropping Mr Brown?

I mean Mr Brown gave some private opinions and PAP replied. End of story.

Let the people decide who is right and who is wrong.
Not PAP or Mediacorp.

There is no need to drop Mr Brown and make this issue a political fight between PAP and Anti-PAP.

In fact, it is Mediacorp who is politicising the whole issue. It is Mediacorp who is partisan.

Anonymous said...

Please suspend all the Pro PAP Journalists as well for being partisan and politicised.

There are train loads of them. Everyday churning out Pro PAP news until like PAP is God.

They paint Opposition like demons so they are partisan as well.

Please be fair in implementing laws(if any) and policy.

I can name some for you: Chua sisters, Loh Chee Kong, Aaron Low, Nicholas Fang etc.

Please suspend all of them as well.

Eugene Neu said...

I'd comment, but then I might get my chances at being a journalist shot in future wouldn't I? *sarcasm*

Good shots all around prof as usual, though whaddaya think of TST quoting you?

Gerald said...

MICA's letter to TODAY was excessively harsh and unnecessary. However, I doubt TODAY received instructions from the government to drop mr brown. It was an over-reaction. By going all the way and suspending mr brown's column, when its editors could have just been more selective in publishing his commentaries, TODAY has demonstrated its willingness to "go the extra mile" to second guess what it thinks the Government Ministers want to see.

singaporepatriot.blogspot.com

simplesandra said...

Nice post. Too bad the Straits Times quoted you out of context, though. :)

haveahacks said...

Regarding sg_patriot's post, actually, I think it would have been far worse for Today to have been "selective" in publishing his columns than to have dropped it entirely. If it starts selectively toning down his columns, or worse, persuading Mr Brown to self-tone-down his columns, we are back in the Straits Times model.

Back during the apartheid era in South Africa, the government demanded that a newspaper drop a particular article. The newspaper complied by simply leaving a blank space where the article would otherwise have been. Sometimes the dogs that don't bark are the most reliable witnesses.

As political commentary, Mr Brown's latest podcast (http://www.mrbrownshow.com/?p=118) was masterful. My respect for his talent has gone up many notches. See ? Who says engineers aren't good at expressing themselves ?

Anonymous said...

Are the following "light touches?"

Nov 2001 : Police arrested internet critic Robert Ho Chong at his home after being charged with an offence punishable by up to three years in jail. The 51-year-old former journalist had posted articles before the general elections urging opposition candidates to enter polling stations, as did the PAP leaders in the 1997 elections. The police classified Ho's article as an attempt to incite violence or disobedience to the law that was likely to lead to a breach of peace.

Jul 2002 : The police again raided internet critic Robert Ho's home and confiscated his computer for two articles posted on soc.culture.singapore. On the same night, social activist Zulfikar Mohamad also had his computer carted away by the police for an article posted on fateha.com. Both postings had raised the issue of nepotism. The two men were being investigated for criminal defamation which can result in a prison sentence of up to 2 years, a fine, or both. Mr Ho complained that, 2 weeks after seizure of his computer, authorities had compelled him to stay in a mental facility for more than a week. Zulfikar Mohamad has since left for Australia.

Aug 2002 : Bloomberg news service publicly apologized and agreed to pay $595,000 in damages to Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong and Senior Minister Lee Kuan Yew for an internet-distributed column which had alleged that Ms Ho Ching, Deputy Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong's wife, was promoted to the senior position in government investment firm Temasek Holdings because of her relationship with the senior leadership.

Sep 2005 : FinanceAsia.com, an Asian online publication, issued an apology and agreed to pay an unspecified amount of damages and legal costs to PM Lee Hsien Loong, SM Goh Chok Tong and MM Lee Kuan Yew for an article about the Lee family and Temasek Holdings.

Oct 2005 : Two bloggers who allegedly posted racist remarks online were sentenced to jail under the Sedition Act, a colonial-era law used by the British to fight communist insurgency, and invoked for the first time since independence. In the same month, sedition charges were also brought against another blogger who allegedly posted inflammatory remarks about Muslims. The district court placed the 17-year old student on probation.

Anonymous said...

Orange County SEO Companies fall short of, Atomic SEO, with their world class staff, the firm seems to keep a client priveledge like no other seo firm.

products said...

China Wholesale has been described as the world’s factory. This phenomenom is typified by the rise ofbusiness. Incredible range of products available with China Wholesalers “Low Price and High Quality” not only reaches directly to their target clients worldwide but also ensures that wholesale from china from China means margins you cannot find elsewhere and buy products wholesaleChina Wholesale will skyroket your profits.

products said...

Women’s nike tn Shox Rivalry est le modèle féminin le plus tendance de baskets pour le sport. tn chaussuresConcernant la semelle :Cheap Brand Jeans ShopMen JeansCheap Jeans - True Religion Jeans nike shoes & Puma Shoes Online- tn nike, le caoutchouc extérieur, l’EVA intermédiaire et le textile intérieur s’associent pour attribuer à la.ed hardy shirts pretty fitCharlestoncheap columbia jackets. turned a pair of double plays to do the trick.Lacoste Polo Shirts, , Burberry Polo Shirts.wholesale Lacoste polo shirts and cheap polo shirtswith great price.Thank you so much!!cheap polo shirts men'ssweate,gillette mach3 razor bladesfor men.As for

dfadf said...

The Tax Return Crack-Up<2>
I was not shocked because this was old news -- practically ancient, in fact. In R. Microsoft Office Emmett Tyrrell, Office 2010 Jr.'s most recent book The Clinton Microsoft Office 2010 Crack-
Up, page fiv Office 2007 e, paragraph two, we learn that in Bill Clinton's "first four years out of the White H Microsoft Office 2007 ouse, he ea Office 2010 key rned over Office 2010 download $43 million Office 2010 Professional after
expenses... Microsoft outlook "
The next Outlook 2010 page directs Windows 7 us to Appendix Microsoft outlook 2010 I, a list of the conniving couple's fees for speeches and book royalties and other income. The first

hibeyond said...

black boots

Chocolate boots

sand boots

Chestnut boots

gray boots

pink boots

grey boots
pink boots on sale


Black Ugg Boots

Chestnut Ugg

Boots


Chocolate Ugg

Boots


Grey Ugg Boots

Ugg Boots On Sale

hibeyond said...

http://holmansbiotechipblog.blogspot.com/2009/03/biotech-and-pharma-provide-little.html

yyyy said...

buy eden gold
Runescape gold
buy Runescape gold

cheap wow gold
cheapest wow gold
lotro gold

Anonymous said...

buy eden gold
eden gold
cheap eden gold

RS Gold said...

I just compulsory some good info and also ended up being searching for The search engines for doing this. I seen for each one paginate in which came out along inaugural page along with didn’MT got every relevant result however thought to browse the second base i and also your blog. And this I need to!

runescape gold
rs gold

Runescape Gold said...

Superb! Generally I never read whole articles but the way you wrote this information is simply amazing and this kept my interest in reading and I enjoyed it.

http://rsgoldb2c1004.eblog.cz/by-using-these-runescape-cheats-hints-and-tips-you-are-able-to-maximize-your-playtime
http://www.freeblog.com.br/rsgoldb2c1004/461905/By+using+these+Runescape+cheats%2C+hints+and+tips+you+are+able+to+maximize+your+playtime..html

Buy Cheap RS Gold said...

Thank you for sharing. Glad to see you.It is really a good post.http://tryplaywow.com/

UCVHOST said...

good work

HP workstations services
web development company

Runescape Gold said...

Thanks for finding the time to discuss this, I am strongly about it and love learning more about this topic. If possible, when you gain expertise, does one mind updating your blog site to comprehend information? It is very of great help for me.
Sell RS Gold
Runescape Gold for Sale
RS Gold
RS GP

teralifeonline said...

While actively playing Runescape, I usually buy swtor credits from reliable web-sites. The principal intent of getting gold from this website is, the website is trusted and provides cheap swtor credits even although in the swtor credits market.

cambridge satchels said...

In the woman fashion life, there are must be several bags, Cambridge Satchel will be your necessity. Now introduced you how to maintain your fashion bags. So beautiful ladies have to pay more and more attention, so make your bags have a longer life or look brand-new.

Fashionable female bag daily maintenance should notice the following aspects:

1. To keep dry, stored in the ventilation and cool and refreshing place.

2. Avoid by all means is insolate, grilled, washing, sharp objects hit and contact chemical solvents.

3. If the purse wet, can use first dry towel blot moisture, again put the newspaper or clean toilet paper tucked into leather bag, and store in a cool place ventilation air drying, don't direct insolate in the sun, it will make leather bag fade, deformation.

4. Sanded skin avoid by all means is wet water, should be with raw rubber wipe or use special care products.

5. Should be careful to protect all metal parts, wet and salt high environment will cause oxidation.

6. Leather purse need not when, had better in cotton cloth bag save, don't put in the plastic bags, plastic bag because air does not circulation, can make the leather dry and damaged. Bags into soft tissue paper or best some newspapers, to keep the shape of the bag. If do not have the appropriate bag, old pillowcase is also applicable.
7. Use the same bag every day, it is easy to cause the elasticity of the cortex tired, so best several leather bags used alternately.

Against the foreign factors on the leather violations, the following are a few the most common can damage leather examples and processing methods.

1. Besmirch spots: with clean sponge with mild soap is, white wine or alcohol KaiMa dirt, then wipe with a clean with clear water, then let the leather dry naturally. If besmirch is very stubborn, you can use cleaner solution to deal with, but be careful KaiMa, avoid damage leather surface.

2. High temperature and the sun: try not to let the purse with the sunlight contact or close to any heaters, or leather bags will become more and more dry, and leather flexibility and softness also will slowly disappear.

3. Juice: right away with clean dishcloth or sponge wiped off the juice will be dry, if need be, can use dishcloth with clean warm water erase juice, again let leather dry naturally.

4. Butter or oil: with a clean cloth to wipe the surface of the grease, let the rest of the oily be soiled insinuates itself into leather inside, don't water to KaiMa stain.
After all, hope all your Cambridge satchels will be ok and enjoy good quality. I think these tips will benefit you a lot.

Anonymous said...

I assume simply PAP is Buy Cheap RS Goldcorrect as well as residents tend to be drastically wrong over these Forms of scenario. These KINDS of predicament have recurring often times over theBuy MapleStory Mesos years.

Ding Michelle said...

Having gold jewelry, the real fantastic thing handbags onlineabout somebody equates of course. Them stresses the beauty led faucetinside of a less pricey method with out inhibiting your look along with the good quality.

Anonymous said...

To get this sort of critters you undoubtedly dog collar require being urged to assist you to certify that possibly enjoying all the presents and they are near practical fitness once review. If you've gained over one puppy, subsequent the rrs really a must as you would like make sure that the dog carrier kitties may be within the perfect luxury combined with physical health whereas you have been off. Despite the presence of individuals devoid of everyone all round, certify they are being satisfied and content such as www.lovelonglong.com you are going to have them till you go back.

Anonymous said...

good
obat alami atasi kemaluan bernanah
obat alami untuk atasi kemaluan bernanah
pengobatan alami atasi kemaluan bernanah
obat atasi kemaluan bernanah
obat alami kemaluan bernanah
obat herbal atasi kemaluan bernanah
obat herbal kemaluan bernanah
obat atasi kemaluan bernanah
pengobatan herbal atasi kemaluan bernanah
obat herbal untuk atasi kemaluan bernanah
Cari Obat Atasi Kemaluan Bernanah
Cari Obat alami Atasi Kemaluan Bernanah
Cari Obat ampuh Atasi Kemaluan Bernanah
Cari Obat Kemaluan Bernanah
Cari Obat herbal Atasi Kemaluan Bernanah
resep obat atasi kemaluan bernanah
resep obat kemaluan bernanah
resep atasi kemaluan bernanah
resep pengobatan alami atasi kemaluan bernanah
resep obat alami atasi kemaluan bernanah
jual obat atasi kemaluan bernanah
jual obat kemaluan bernanah
obat atasi kemaluan bernanah
jual obat alami kemaluan bernanah
jual obat untuk atasi kemaluan bernanah
kumpulan obat atasi kemaluan bernanah
kumpulan obat kemaluan bernanah
kumpulan pengobatan untuk atasi kemaluan bernanah
kumpulan obat untuk atasi kemaluan bernanah
kumpulan obat untuk kemaluan bernanah
obat herbal untuk wasir paling ampuh
obat herbal untuk wasir
obat untuk wasir paling ampuh
obat herbal untuk wasir ampuh
pengobatan herbal untuk wasir paling ampuh
obat tradisional untuk wasir paling ampuh
obat untuk wasir paling ampuh
obat tradisional untuk wasir
obat tradisional untuk wasir ampuh
pengobatan tradisional untuk wasir paling ampuh
Obat Alternatif Untuk Wasir Paling Ampuh
Obat Alternatif Untuk Wasir
Obat Alternatif Wasir Paling Ampuh

herbalku ampuh said...

good article
beli obat kutil pada kemaluan wanita
Obat Kutil Pada Sekitar Kemaluan Wanita
Obat Alami Kutil Pada Sekitar Kemaluan Wanita
Jual Obat Kutil Pada Sekitar Kemaluan Wanita
Obat Ampuh Atasi Kutil Pada Sekitar Kemaluan Wanita
Obat Kutil Pada Sekitar Kemaluan Wanita Tanpa Operasi
Obat Kutil Pada Daerah Kemaluan Wanita
Obat Kutil Pada Daerah Kemaluan Wanita Yang Manjur
Obat Kutil Pada Daerah Kemaluan Wanita Resep Dokter

kurnia tani said...

gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci partai
gantungan kunci bahan akrilik
gantungan kunci
pusat gantungan kunci jogja
kado cantik
cara pemesanan ganci
testimoni ganci
gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci
papan strategi
gantungan kunci pemain
cara pemesanan
papan strategi bola
gantungan kunci pemain bola
gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci 2 muka
gantungan kunci foto
gantungan kunci foto
gantungan kunci akrilik untuk kenangan

kurnia tani said...

gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci dealer
gantungan kunci bahan akrilik cetak
gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci kado
gantungan kunci akrilik untuk hadiah
gantungan kunci
grosir souvenir cantik
gantungan kunci cindera mata
souvenir dan gantungan kunci unik
gantungan kunci
grosir souvenir online
grosir souvenir cantik dan murah
grosir souvenir unik
gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci jogja
gantungan kunci
pesan gantungan kunci akrilik untuk
gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci hotel

kurnia tani said...

gantungan kunci akrilik untuk
gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci cinderamata
pesan gantungan kunci akrilik
gantungan kunci
pusat souvenir jogja
gantungan kunci dan souvenir
cinderamata ganci
kado gantungan kunci
papan strategi bola
cara pemesanan ganci
testimoni pelanggan ganci
gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci aklilik
souvenir cntik murah
souvenir dan gantungan kunci unik
cara order souvenir
testimoni pelanggan gancijogja
pesan gantungan kunci akrilik
pesan gantungan kunci
gantungan kunci akrilik

Anonymous said...

good
Pengobatan keluar nanah dari kemaluan laki laki
obat keluar nanah dari kemaluan laki laki
keluar nanah kemaluan laki laki
keluar nanah dari kemaluan laki-laki
Penyebab Keluar Nanah Kemaluan Laki-laki
Penyebab Keluar Nanah di Kemaluan Laki-laki
Penyebab Keluar Nanah dari Kemaluan
Penyebab Keluar Nanah dari Kemaluan Laki laki
Obat Keluar Nanah dari Ujung Kemaluan Laki-laki
Keluar Nanah di Ujung Kemaluan Laki-laki
Pengobatan Keluar Nanah dari Ujung Kemaluan Laki-laki
Keluar Nanah Ujung Kemaluan Laki-laki
Keluar Cairan Nanah Kemaluan Laki-laki
Keluar Cairan Nanah di Kemaluan Laki-laki
Pengobatan Keluar Cairan Nanah dari Kemaluan Laki-laki
Keluar Nanah dari Kemaluan Laki-laki
obat ambeien manjur
obat ambeien yang paling manjur
obat ambeyen yang manjur
pengobatan ambeien yang manjur
Obat Ambeien Manjur di Apotik
Obat Ambeyen yang Manjur di Apotik
Pengobatan Ambeien yang Manjur di Apotik
Obat Ambeien yang Manjur Apotik
Obat Ambeyen Alami yang Manjur
Obat Ambeien Alami Manjur
Pengobatan Ambeien Alami yang Manjur
Obat Untuk Ambeien Alami yang Manjur
Obat Ambeien Paling Manjur
Obat Ambeien yang Paling Ampuh
Obat Ambeyen yang Paling Manjur
Pengobatan Ambeien yang Paling Manjur
Pengobatan Ampuh Kanker Serviks
Pengobatan Alami Kanker Serviks
Pengobatan Herbal Kanker Serviks
Pengobatan Tradisional Kanker Serviks