Sunday, April 23, 2006

POLITICAL MANAGEMENT OF BLOGS

The legal position of blogs during the election period has been clarified, but intriguing questions remain about how these alternative media might behave, and what the government's response might be. There are certainly loopholes that enterprising media activists can exploit. First, they can use the web until they are asked to register as political sites. Second, they can restrict themselves to using email, which is outside the ambit of the registration requirement. Third, they can host their sites overseas. In the first two scenarios, they would still be subject to "post-publication" punishment if they fall foul of defamation or other laws. However, they are not subject to "prior restraint" (being shut up even before saying anything, which is what discretionary licensing and banning amounts to, and which is regarded in free speech discourse as the most illiberal form of control).

In one possible scenario, all but a small handful of internet users will be sufficiently spooked by the government warnings that they will self-censor. The confusion surrounding the rules makes this scenario more likely. The newspaper, Today, contributed to this confusion in an article on 21 April. Attempting to educate readers about the rules now that the election writ had been issued, Today declared: "From now on, the gloves have to stay on. For bloggers, that is." It added: "What this means is that all political parties and individuals not registered with the Media Development Authority are not allowed to indulge in anything that can be construed as campaigning - until the elections are over." This is completely wrong. Parties can in fact use the internet for campaigning; they just can't use some of its multimedia and interactive features. As for individuals, they are free to use the internet as long as they are not asked to register - precisely the opposite of what Today claimed.

A second scenario, at the other extreme, is that a large number of Singaporeans will exploit the existing loopholes, emboldened by their relatively unfettered use of the medium for the past several years. This will put the government in a dilemma. The fact is that the Singapore government, while infamous for its intolerance of dissent, has never been one to go after large numbers of ordinary citizens. Its actions have been mainly against professional politicians and the occasional individual who is deemed to be a political opponent. If the government now tries to prosecute 10, 20 individuals for breaching internet electioneering rules, it would be entering uncharted political territory. It will be extremely difficult to convince the majority of Singaporeans that such individuals really are a threat to stability, if the offenders are just ordinary Singaporeans and if their online comments are not particularly inflammatory. Trying to prosecute them would be a public relations fiasco.

One of the remaining grey areas is the status of sites that may try to provide independent news coverage of the elections, as opposed to highly-opinionated commentary. As noted in an earlier posting below, the letter of the law provides an exception to licensed news providers (newspapers and broadcasters), including their websites. Thus, anything that Straits Times Interactive carries - including podcasts, streaming video, editorials telling Singaporeans how to vote, etc - is exempt from the internet electioneering laws. Independent sites are not, even if their content is identical. However, a group of media activists that tries to provide independent news reports on their website could, if challenged, argue that they are keeping to the spirit of the election rules, in that they are dealing in news, not advertising. The government may still win the legal argument on technical grounds, but it would probably lose the moral argument: it is going to be hard to persuade public opinion that independent citizens who abide by the standards of professional journalism do not deserve the same treatment as the institutional media. That would be tantamount to saying that WHO speaks is more important than WHAT they say.

In parallel with the legal response, the government is also engaged in rhetorical campaign against alternative media. Blogging (which is merely a technology for easily editing websites, and has been put to a wide variety of uses) is being routinely stereotyped as mere entertainment, in an attempt to delegitimise the form in the eyes of the majority of Singaporeans who may not be technologically literate enough to know better. Visual media are being described as more emotional. Print media, on the other hand, are being associated with more rational and responsible discourse. However, this does not mean that print is subject to more relaxed regulation: since colonial times, newspapers and magazines have been subject to discretionary licensing.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

Making holic gold is the old question : Honestly there is no fast way to make lots of holic money . Sadly enough a lot of the people that all of a sudden come to with millions of holic online gold almost overnight probably duped . Although there are a lot of ways to make lots of cheap holic goldhere I will tell you all of the ways that I know and what I do to make holic online money.

As a new player , you may need some game guides or information to enhance yourself.
kal geons is one of the hardest theme for every class at the beginning . You must have a good way to manage your kal gold.If yor are a lucky guy ,you can earn so many kal online geons by yourself . But if you are a not , I just find a nice way to get kal online gold. If you need , you can buy kalonline Geons at our website . Go to the related page and check the detailed information . Once you have any question , you can connect our customer service at any time .

Anonymous said...

Hi All :)

Your article is great. Thanks for information. I'ts very useful. You have very nice blog.

------------------------------------------
Free Poker Bonus No Deposit Required - Sign up Promotions.
Free Poker bankrolls - Regards

pedro velasquez said...

Whether sportsbook you're a newly minted blogger or a relative old-timer, you've been seeing more and more stories pop up every day about bloggers getting in trouble for what they post. Like all journalists and publishers, bloggers sometimes publish information that other people don't bet nfl want published. You might, for example, publish something that someone considers defamatory, republish an AP news story that's under copyright, or write a lengthy piece detailing the alleged crimes of a candidate for public office. sportsbook The difference between you and the reporter at your local newspaper is that in many cases, you may not have the benefit of training or resources to help you determine whether what you're doing is legal. And on top of that, sometimes knowing the law doesn't help - in many cases it was written for traditional journalists, http://www.enterbet.com and the courts haven't yet decided how it applies to bloggers.

free mp3 music said...

This site is a good site,it tells about New Media, Politics & the Law - Atom free mp3 music .

free mp3 music said...

really,your site is well about A Chemical Sabbatical.i would like to post my site free mp3 music .

kimberly sayer said...

Prior restraint is a legal term related to censorship in the United States referring to government actions that prevent communications from reaching the public.costa rica fishingIts main use is to keep materials from being published. Censorship that requires a person to seek governmental permission in the form of a license or imprimatur before publishing anything constitutes prior restraint every time permission is denied.
http://www.fishingcostaricaexperts.com

Anonymous said...

Prior restraint is often considered a particularly oppressive form of censorship in Anglo-American jurisprudence because it prevents the restricted material from being heard or distributed at all.Costa rica toursOther forms of restrictions on expression (such as suits for libel, slander, defamation, or actions for criminal libel) generally involve punishment only after the offending material has been published.
http://www.kingtours.com

UCVHOST said...

nice blog well written

HP workstations services
web development company

Anonymous said...

The real difference
Runescape Gold in between anyone with a media reporter at the nearby magazine is in many cases, may very well not contain the benefit for instruction as well as means to help you decideSell Rs Goldif your work is actually legitimate.

love supra said...

All's for the best in the best of all possible worlds! I have not see post good enough like yours here.Just admire your intelligence and informative explanation. I am a wow gamer but can't write such detailed info about that.
More tags: wow gold for cheap /
world of warcraft gold /
wow gold /
cheap wow gold

Unknown said...

nice article.
Obat Alami Kanker Payudara
Obat Alami Untuk Kanker Payudara
Obat Alami Buat Kanker Payudara
Obat Alami Atasi Kanker Payudara
Cari Obat Alami Kanker Payudara

Anonymous said...

good
obat Tradisional Kanker Payudara
Pengobatan Tradisional untuk Kanker Payudara
Pengobatan sakit Kanker Payudara
Pengobatan Tradisional untuk sakit Kanker Payudara
Pengobatan Kanker Payudara
obat Alami Kanker Payudara
Pengobatan Ampuh Kanker Payudara
Pengobatan Alami sakit Kanker Payudara
obat ambeyen tanpa operasi
obat wasir tanpa operasi
pengobatan ambeien tanpa operasi
obat ambeien tanpa harus operasi
Obat Kutil di Area kelamin
Obat Kutil di kemaluan
Obat Kutil Area kemaluan
Obat sakit Kutil di Area kemaluan
Obat Kutil di Area Kemaluan
Obat Kutil di Area Kelamin
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Pria
Pengobatan Kutil di Area Kemaluan Pria
Obat Kutil di Area Kemaluan
Obat sakit Kutil di Area Kemaluan Wanita
Obat Kutil di Kemaluan Wanita
Obat Kutil ampuh di Area Kemaluan Wanita
Cari Obat ampuh Kutil di Area Kemaluan
Cari Obat alami Kutil di Area Kemaluan
Obat Kutil di Area Kemaluan
Cari Obat tradisional Kutil di Area Kemaluan
Terapi Keluar Nanah pada alat kelamin
Keluar Nanah pada Penis
Terapi Keluar Nanah di Penis
cara Terapi Keluar Nanah pada Penis
Gejala sakit Keluar Nanah pada Penis
Keluar Nanah pada Penis
Gejala Keluar Nanah pada alat kelamin
Gejala penyakit Keluar Nanah pada Penis

Solusi 2 Online said...

kiat istri vagina wangi 1
tips istri rahasia vagina wangi
tips istri dengan vagina wangi
cara istri membuat vagina wangi
cara membuat miss v menggigit
cara merapatkan miss v secara alami
obat perapat vagina
kiat istri dengan vagina wangi untuk menggairahkan suami
obat penyempit vagina
obat penyempit atau perapat vagina
obat penyempit vagina super
obat penyempit miss v
krim payudara montok dan seksi
masker payuadara montok dan kencang
obat disayang suami
obat keputihan total
obat miss v gatal
obat peremajaan vagina
obat percantik vagina
menyediakan obat penyempit vagina

Unknown said...

Obat Ambeien Yang Terdaftar di BPOM Ambeien/ wasir sebenarnya bukanlah suatu penyakit melainkan perubahan bentuk dan ukuran pembuluh darah secara anatomis dimana pembuluh darah di sekitar anus bagian dalam mengalami pembesaran dan pelebaran karena dipengaruhi oleh beberapa faktor. http://herbal234.blog.planetbiru.com/?id=8714 , Obat Ambeien Hemoroid yang Paling Manjur Menderita wasir pada saat hamil merupakan hal yang biasa terjadi. Wasir terjadi jika ada pembengkakan pada pembuluh darah balik yang ada di sekitar anus. Wasir terkadang dianggap sepele oleh banyak orang, http://herbal234.blog.com/2016/01/25/obat-ambeien-hemoroid-yang-paling-manjur/ Obat Tradisional Kelamin Bernanah Selain obat dari medis, banyak juga pnegobatan alami yang bisa membantu menyembuhkan kencing nanah. Pengobatan alami kencing nanah dibuat menggunakan bahan alami dari alam sehingga tidak ada efek samping yang muncul. mengenal lebih jauh mengenai kencing nanah, penyakit tersebut diketahui merupakan penyakit yang menular melalui selaput lendir. http://herbal789.pbworks.com/w/page/104476582/Obat%20Tradisional%20Kelamin%20Bernanah , Penyebab Ujung Kemaluan Keluar Nanah Banyak Hal ini juga yang menyebabkan banyaknya penderita yang tidak sadar dirinya telah terinfeksi kencing nanah. Beberapa hari setelah terinfeksi barulah gejalanya timbul itupun tidak mencolok. Pada pria, biasanya ada rasa tidak nyaman pada ureta. http://caramengobati321.blogspot.com/2016/01/penyebab-ujung-kemaluan-keluar-nanah.html Dari Penis Mengeluarkan Seperti Nanah Kental Bakteri yang sudah menyebar pada tenggorokan akan diidentifikasi sebagai faringitis gonokola sedangkan bakteri Neisseria yang menyerang lapisan putih mata disebut sebagai Konjungtiva gonore. http://bellydancersphiladelphia.com/dari-penis-mengeluarkan-seperti-nanah-kental.html , Kemaluan Lelaki Bernanah dan Ngilu Keadaan seperti ini dapat membuat pasien menjadi demam, terutama jika infeksi penyakit ini telah mulai menyebar ke bagian tubuh yang lain. http://herbal234.sosblogs.com/The-first-blog-b1/Kemaluan-Lelaki-Bernanah-dan-Ngilu-b1-p446.htm
http://pengobatanherbal321.blogspot.com/2016/01/menghilangkan-bintil-kutil-di-dekat.html
http://herbal234.blog.com/2016/01/19/cari-obat-untuk-kutil-di-daerah-kemaluan-pria/
http://denatureobatherbal.blogspot.com/2016/01/penyebab-kutil-di-daerah-kemaluan-wanita.html